TraditionalMountaineering Logo - representing the shared 
companionship of the Climb

Home | Information | Photos | Calendar | News | Seminars | Experiences | Questions | Updates | Books | Conditions | Links | Search

  Search this site!
Read more:

US Forest Service to gut Recreation Budget to pay fire fighting costs

U.S. Forest Service to pull funds from recreation, forest health
Last week a reporter contacted me for an article he was writing. Forest Service Chief Gail Kimball had just announced she planned to cut recreation and other programs by $300 million and to transfer that money into fire suppression. The reporter asked for a comment and in addition to what is quoted in the appended article, I explained how this budget transfer was a “twofer.” That line of reasoning didn’t get into the article and so I share it here.

Not only is Kimball moving money into a bottomless pit from which private contractors will eventually receive the lion’s share: in further staving the recreation programs, Kimball could ensure that local land managers would have no option other that to rely even more heavily upon increased and more wide-spread recreation user-fees, volunteerism, partnership and, of course, more commercialization.

With respect to the Forest Service, Congress is not primarily, or uniquely, responsible for using the Reaganesque “Starve the Beast” mechanism to destroy that agency’s recreation program. It is the Forest Service itself, thought a variety of mechanisms, that is gutting its own recreation program.

Top brass within the Forest Service are minimizing the amount of allocated dollars that get to the ground. The more conspicuously the Forest Service does this, the more “inefficient” they are seen to be and the more impetus there becomes for cutting the agency’s budget.

Sadly, the current administration values those employees who exhibit special competence in destroying their own agencies and showing to all the world, that government does not work and should, therefore, be privatized.
--Contributed by Scott Silver, Wild Wilderness


Fire costs will again thin other budgets -
U.S. Forest Service to pull funds from recreation, forest health
by Keith Chu
The Bulletin
November 2, 2007

WASHINGTON - After another fire season that exceeded U.S. Forest Service expectations, agency Chief Gail Kimbell said firefighting costs will continue to burn up money for recreation and forest health funding into next year’s budget.

Kimbell said the Forest Service spent $100 million more than it budgeted for firefighting in the 2007 fiscal year. She told the U.S. House Committee on Global Warming on Thursday that she already has begun pulling money from non-fire programs to pay for an even larger firefighting budget in the 2009 fiscal year.

Kimbell’s announcement likely means a continuation of cuts to recreation budgets in Central Oregon and points to the need for more forest thinning to prevent catastrophic and expensive fires, according to House members and local trail advocates.
Congressmen at the hearing said the agency cannot continue to cut other functions to feed the growing maw of fire costs.

“You’re already cannibalizing the budget,” said Rep. Earl Blumenauer, D-Portland. “You have to thin all of your activities (because of) this exploding cost.”
Kimbell said the Forest Service spent $1.34 billion fighting fires in the 2007 fiscal year and exceeded its budget, even after Congress set aside $375 million in emergency wildfire funding.

Wildfires consumed nearly 600,000 acres of forests and grassland in Oregon this year, ranking it sixth among states. The GW Fire northwest of Sisters burned 7,500 acres, while the Egley Complex of fires near Burns burned 140,000 acres.

Rep. Greg Walden, R-Hood River, said changes in forest policy are the only way to stop ever-higher fire spending.

“We had half-a-million acres burn in my state this year; this is getting out of control,” said Walden, who represents Eastern, Central and parts of Southern Oregon.

Walden advocated increased salvage logging after forest fires to improve forest health and because young trees absorb the greenhouse gas carbon dioxide, which dead trees do not.

“If you replant sooner, you’re going to produce forests sooner, and you’re going to sequester carbon sooner,” he said.

Scott Silver, of the Bend-based conservation group Wild Wilderness, said he’s not sure what the Forest Service should do to attack the increasing fire activity. But he knows throwing money at the problem isn’t the answer.

“Fire suppression could use every dollar people want to spend on it,” Silver said. “The question may be, is it appropriate to declare war on fire and fight it as if it were a war, or is it more appropriate to rethink our policy?”

When the fire budget is exhausted, the Forest Service initiates “fire transfers” - loans from other programs to pay for firefighting costs. Congress is supposed to reimburse local districts for those transfers, but historically has repaid only about 80 percent of transfers, according to a 2004 Government Accountability Office study.

In the 2007 fiscal year, the Forest Service pulled $731,000 from Deschutes National Forest programs and $32,600 from the Ochoco National Forest. In the Ochoco, most of that money came from recreation programs, while in the Deschutes, it was pulled from a variety of programs, including watershed enhancement, air resources and fire preparedness, the Deschutes National Forest reported.

Volunteers who have already taken responsibility to maintain hundreds of miles of trails are leery of even deeper cuts to recreation budgets, said Kent Howes, president of the Bend-based Central Oregon Trails Alliance.

“To us, they already told us they have no money, so how much less is that?” Howes said. “I’m sure there will be a few more trailheads closed somewhere, a few more privies that get locked up and don’t get pumped out and that hurts everybody out here.”

The outlook doesn’t look any better in 2009, Kimbell said.

“In preparing the fiscal year 2009 budget, I’ve (had to) find $300 million from other projects to move into fire suppression,” Kimbell said, in response to a question from Walden.

Locally, that funding shortfall has left volunteer groups like the Central Oregon Trails Alliance to fill the gap. So far this year, the group has spent 2,500 hours maintaining local trails, up from 1,700 hours last year, Howes said.

“If we don’t do something about it, they’re just going to get closed or not maintained,” Howes said. “They’re going to go away, and no one wants that.”





Read more . . .
Leave No Trace
IMBA builds trails with the Central Oregon Trails Alliance
BLM partners with Friends of the Badlands
Wilderness trail closures by BLM's Friends of the badlands
Oregon Natural Desert Association - ONDA

Photos of a Wilderness inventory near Juntura, in eastern Oregon
ONDA survey of Owyhee Canyon
Owyhee Canyon Wilderness study area
Oregon's Owyhee River inventory delivered to BLM
About the Owyhee River wilderness inventory with ONDA

Pulling barbed wire fence at the Hart Mountain Antelope Refuge with ONDA
Scenes from an ODFW - STEP volunteer 1,000 mile drive around eastern Oregon
Backpacking Big Indian Gorge in The Steens   
NOLS group on an Owyhee River Canyon adventure
Owyhee River desert lands - Jordan Valley Rodeo
Steens Mountain wedding in Eastern Oregon

Badlands wilderness trail closures
Bend Oregon Badlands WSA hiking map available from BLM
Hunters who use ATVs are hurting Oregon's elk population
BLM's final UDRMP opens Bend's Badlands to Geocaching
BLM's final UDRMP closes Bend's Badlands WSA to motorized vehicle use
Wilderness workshop for USDA Forest Service held by University of Idaho
BLM's UDRMP plans for Badlands deal with exploding public use
Map, compass and GPS navigation training Noodle in The Badlands
Deschutes County Commissioners fail to support Badlands Wilderness!
Deschutes County takes no position on Badlands Wilderness
Deschutes County Commissioner DeWolf supports Badlands Wilderness
OpEd - Dirt road through The Badlands must close
Photos of Road 8 damage sent to Commissioners
Badlands Wilderness with a road?
The Badlands have unique interest for the hiker
BLM guidelines for Geocaching on public lands
Geocaching on Federal Forest Lands
OpEd - Geocaching should not be banned in the Badlands
Fee Demo groundwork may save Geocaching on our public lands
Protest of exclusion of Geocaching in Badlands WSA in BLM's UDRMP
BLM's UDRMP puts Bend's Badlands off limits to Geocaching
Deschutes County Commissioners hearing on Badlands Wilderness support
OHV use restricted in Upper Deschutes Resource Management Plan
Winter hiking in The Badlands WSA just east of Bend
Tread Lightly OHV USFS tip of the month
OHVs to be held to designated trails by USDA Forest Service!
New pole shows Badlands Wilderness favored by voters
BLM posts Reward for information on Juniper rustlers
BLM weighing public input on management plan
Oregon's Badlands hit by old growth Juniper rustlers  Photos
Congressman Greg Walden to visit The Badlands
Badlands Wilderness endorsed by COTA
OpEd - Unregulated OHV use is being reviewed across the western states
OHV use curtailed by new USFS policy decisions
Sierra Club's Juniper Group supports Badlands Wilderness
OHV regulation discussed at BLM meeting in Bend, Oregon
OpEd - Badlands part of BLM's recreation management area
OpEd - We need the Badlands Wilderness
OpEd - Off-roaders have no reason to fear Badlands Wilderness designation
Speak for the Badlands at Town Hall Meeting
Hiking poles are becoming essential gear
Vandals destroy ancient pictographs in the Badlands
Senator Wyden tests support of Badlands Wilderness
Badlands Wilderness endorsed by Bend City Commissioners
The Badlands: proposed for Wilderness status
The Badlands unique geologic forms explained by Chitwood  pdf
The Badlands, a brief history
The Badlands pictographs reported 75 year ago

USFS Five Buttes Healthy Forest fire reduction program in Central Oregon
Bob McGown, AAC Section Chair, builds a telescope pad at Pine Mountain Observatory
Becoming an Outdoors Woman classes in LaPine, Oregon with the ODFW
Pulling barbed wire fence at the Hart Mountain Antelope Refuge with ONDA
A tour of the aftermath of the B & B forest fire with the Sierra Club
Adopt-a-Road with TraditionalMountaineering
The Bend Bicycle Festival 2004
Wolves introduced to the High Desert Museum
Twenty old growth Juniper stolen from The Badlands WSA   More information
A sustainable way to use feathers to adorn my lady
ODFW clinic - Becoming an Outdoors Woman
President Bush holds photo opportunities
Trail Crew builds a log bridge over Spring Creek
Sierra Club holds a Christmas party
Tour fire ravaged Davis Lake
IMBA helps COTA build trails
South Sister climbers trail relocated
President Bush hopes no child will be left behind
Adopt-A-Highway with TraditionalMountaineering
Department of Inferior dumps wilderness protection
An ODFW juvenile steelhead sampling project near John Day, Oregon
The ODFW juvenile steelhead survey in the stream
Owyhee Canyon wilderness study area in south east Oregon
ONDA's Owyhee wilderness inventory camp near Rome, Oregon
Riverfest river cleanup in Bend Oregon
USFS Mud Bog poster
A Pay to Play bust
President Bush reassures us that SUVs do not damage the environment!
President Bush overlooking the environment
Al Gore and his young son summit Mt. Rainier
Fee Demo demonstration in Central Oregon