www.TraditionalMountaineering.org ™ and also www.AlpineMountaineering.org ™
FREE BASIC TO ADVANCED
ALPINE MOUNTAIN CLIMBING INSTRUCTION™
Home | Information | Photos | Calendar | News | Seminars | Experiences | Questions | Updates | Books | Conditions | Links | Search
Search this site!
IN MY VIEW
Op-Ed to The Bulletin
by Robert Speik
January 3, 2003
Restrict off-highway vehicle access
Off Highway Vehicle (OHV) use is being reviewed by public Land Managers across the western states, according to an article by Courtney Lowery for The Associated Press, reprinted on November 26, 2003 by The Bulletin. When Dale Bosworth recently became Forest Service Chief, according to the article, he said that unregulated recreation, specifically off highway vehicle use, or “OHV” use, was a major threat to the national forests.
Souped up 4 X 4s, All Terrain Vehicles (four wheeled ATVs) and motorcycles of all types can quickly create their own illegal trails across virgin land. One rider follows another and soon one more wide, rutted dusty road is marked for years.
OHV trails are not suitable for shared use. A non-mechanized recreationist, who might try to share the trails, must keep his eyes and ears open for fast approaching, helmeted and often leathered riders who sometimes seem committed to intimidating the very land they ride over. Horses, dogs and children particularly, cannot share OHV trails, not to mention hunters, birders and Scouts.
Several months ago, I wrote an essay for In My View, to point out that there was plenty of room for OHV use and separate, quiet, human powered use on our high desert lands east of Bend. The piece was generally well received except for a few hardheaded folks who were unwilling to give up just 10 miles of their 640 miles of approved OHV trails for the popular Badlands Wilderness proposal. Full time BLM and Forest Service OHV Recreation Specialists, who are funded in part, by our Oregon gas tax dollars, maintain for their exclusive use these trails on 200,000 dedicated acres.
In another recent In My View piece, Mollie Chaudet, Project Manager for the Upper Deschutes Resource Management Plan (UDRMP), explained the need to set guidelines for recreational OHV use in the vast study area managed by the BLM east of Bend and extending from Redmond to La Pine. Historically, unrestricted OHV use over all USFS and BLM managed lands did not pose a significant problem due to the limited numbers mechanized recreationists. While the Plan will exclude OHV use in the Badlands Wilderness Study Area, this move to regulate OHV use in portions of this vast BLM area is not related to our small Badlands Wilderness, but to regulation by Land Managers across the West.
Another group of recreationists, mechanized but human powered, have evidenced a more friendly attitude toward hikers whom they invite to use their extensive network of delightful single track trails in areas west of Bend and along Horse Ridge to the east. The Central Oregon Trails Alliance (COTA) builds these subtle shared use trails without gas tax dollar support and with Forest Service approval. Illegal ATV use has damaged some of these trails. COTA has joined with the Oregon Natural Desert Association (ONDA) in supporting BLM restriction of OHV use in The Badlands Wilderness Study Area.
Recently, real concerns have surfaced over the personal safety of the growing numbers of skiers and snow shoers in the area of Dutchman Flat. A Nordic skier struck by an unregulated snowmachine traveling at highway speed will certainly be badly hurt or killed. The Forest Service clearly agreed the problem did exist and planned to set a reasonable speed limit of 25 miles per hour on Dutchman Flat, but then changed the decision reportedly due to a lack of funds for enforcement.
It might be noted that the snowmobile clubs provide financial support for the Sheriff’s uniformed snowmachine mounted law enforcement officers. The funds in part come from their own allocation of our Oregon gas tax dollars. I am not sure whether or not the snowmobile clubs have been asked to help finance the enforcement of Dutchman Flat speed limits.
I see a relationship between the concern for unregulated use of both OHVs and snowmachines. While some skiers and snowshoers are delighted to share groomed snowmachine trails, many have expressed concern regarding the high-speed play of some snowmobilers in close proximity to themselves and their children. Recently, according to an AP article reprinted in The Bulletin, a Federal Judge ruled illegal, a Bush Administration order that would have permitted the return of the almost 1,000 snowmachine thrill rides per day in Yellowstone, which rides had been banned under President Clinton. The conflict with animals and people in Yellowstone has been well documented.
Mechanized recreationists should see that there are serious concerns and try their level best to work sincerely, with Land Managers and those folks who do not wish to, or can not afford to, own the expensive, noisy toys that some love to ride.
Robert Speik writes about his active retirement outdoor adventures for TraditionalMountaineering.org
IN MY VIEW
Op-Ed to the Bulletin
by Bruce Jarmie
January 20, 2004
ANTI-OHV PEOPLE ARE
SIMPLY TRYING TO STAGE A LAND GRAB
It continues to astonish me how anti off-highway vehicle (OHV) rhetoric attempts to sway our public agencies as well as the public at large with portents of doom that OHV usage will bring to our Central Oregon public lands.
Robert Speik, in his Jan. 3 "Restrict off-highway vehicle access" opinion, uses partial facts and insinuation in an attempt to instill fear. I love America, the land where everyone can have an opinion, regardless of accuracy. If one is to believe Mr. Speik, all off-roaders ride souped-up vehicles, make illegal trails, intimidate other people, including children, and the very land we ride on. My, what despicable people we all must be!
How easy it is to ignore the facts of what really constitutes OHV usage here in Central Oregon. As one of the "hardheaded" individuals referred to, who is against restricting OHV usage in our popular Badlands area, I would encourage you to understand that there are very serious concerns about diminishing OHV opportunities here in Central Oregon. Since you feel strongly about restricting OHV usage, why don't we look at the fine example our California brethren have provided for us.
For the past 30 years, they have embarked upon a plan of restricting OHV usage without planning for the explosive growth and popularity of our sport. Now they have a total lose- lose-lose situation. The OHV community is mad and in the courts suing; environmentalists like you are mad and in court suing; and the land managers are ready to give up because they are in court getting sued all the time.
When you analyzed the hundreds of thousands of acres of public land available for recreation here in Central Oregon, did you realize that there have been no new OHV trails built in over five years? Did you realize that our OHV opportunities have been systematically reduced over this same period? Did you factor in the hundreds of Central Oregonian families who have purchased OHVs in the past five years? We can follow those knowledgeable Californians: We can take an ever-expanding number of OHV families and restrict them to an ever-diminishing number of acres and expect all will turn out well.
After months of debate and oratory from the anti-OHV crowd, I have come to the following conclusion: This is not about sharing trails, being fair and respectful of each other's sports and cooperating towards solutions that best meet the needs of all Central Oregonians. The anti-OHV crowd simply wants to take public land now designated for OHV use that is close and convenient to Bend and dedicate it for their own use. This is a pure and simple land-grab, folks. Want proof? As far as I know, no OHV group has ever tried to stop any other sport from creating trail opportunities for itself. In fact, OHV groups have teamed up with mountain bikers, horse folks and hikers to create harmonious trail opportunities all over this country. Has anyone heard one cooperative word of assistance from our local anti-OHV folks in the past five years?
Mr. Speik, your agenda is revealed! So whether we are talking OHVs in the desert or fast snowmobiles in the mountains, the solution is simple: We need more opportunities, not fewer. Restricting usage won't work any better than Prohibition did in the 1920s. There may be incompatibilities between motorized and nonmotorized recreationalists that cannot be resolved. Closing down motorized areas to satisfy nonmotorized wishes is not a solution. If we have to close a motorized area, then should we not be compensating and opening an equivalent area?
We need to build more areas for OHVs to accommodate a popular and growing family sport. We need to build snowmobile parks and trail systems that are designed for today's snowmobile technology, not yesterday's. We can follow the Californians, or we can blaze our own trails.
Bruce Jarmie is an active OHV and horse owner and has lived in central Oregon for 10 years.
Subscribe to this newspaper now!
This map (and several others like it) was produced by the BLM for the exclusive benefit of OHV owners
We do hope the majority of OHV enthusiasts will actively support a Congressionally mandated Wilderness designation for this small bit of quiet desert called The Badlands.
Read more . . .
The Badlands Wilderness
BLM partners with "Friends of the Badlands" to provide Stewardship for Badlands WSA
Badlands wilderness trail closures
Bend Oregon Badlands WSA hiking map available from BLM
Hunters who use ATVs are hurting Oregon's elk population
BLM's final UDRMP opens Bend's Badlands to Geocaching
BLM's final UDRMP closes Bend's Badlands WSA to motorized vehicle use
Wilderness workshop for USDA Forest Service held by University of Idaho
BLM's UDRMP plans for Badlands deal with exploding public use
Map, compass and GPS navigation training Noodle in The Badlands
Deschutes County Commissioners fail to support Badlands Wilderness!
Deschutes County takes no position on Badlands Wilderness
Deschutes County Commissioner DeWolf supports Badlands Wilderness
OpEd - Dirt road through The Badlands must close
Photos of Road 8 damage sent to Commissioners
Badlands Wilderness with a road?
The Badlands have unique interest for the hiker
BLM guidelines for Geocaching on public lands
Geocaching on Federal Forest Lands
OpEd - Geocaching should not be banned in the Badlands
Fee Demo groundwork may save Geocaching on our public lands
Protest of exclusion of Geocaching in Badlands WSA in BLM's UDRMP
BLM's UDRMP puts Bend's Badlands off limits to Geocaching
Deschutes County Commissioners hearing on Badlands Wilderness support
OHV use restricted in Upper Deschutes Resource Management Plan
Winter hiking in The Badlands WSA just east of Bend
Tread Lightly OHV USFS tip of the month
OHVs to be held to designated trails by USDA Forest Service!
New pole shows Badlands Wilderness favored by voters
BLM posts Reward for information on Juniper rustlers
BLM weighing public input on management plan
Oregon's Badlands hit by old growth Juniper rustlers Photos
Congressman Greg Walden to visit The Badlands
Badlands Wilderness endorsed by COTA
OpEd - Unregulated OHV use is being reviewed across the western states
OHV use curtailed by new USFS policy decisions
Sierra Club's Juniper Group supports Badlands Wilderness
OHV regulation discussed at BLM meeting in Bend, Oregon
OpEd - Badlands part of BLM's recreation management area
OpEd - We need the Badlands Wilderness
OpEd - Off-roaders have no reason to fear Badlands Wilderness designation
Speak for the Badlands at Town Hall Meeting
Hiking poles are becoming essential gear
Vandals destroy ancient pictographs in the Badlands
Senator Wyden tests support of Badlands Wilderness
Badlands Wilderness endorsed by Bend City Commissioners
The Badlands: proposed for Wilderness status
The Badlands unique geologic forms explained by Chitwood pdf
The Badlands, a brief history
The Badlands pictographs reported 75 year ago
Leave no Trace with Restop bags
Mountaineering blue bag, WAG bag and Restop bag waste solutions in 1985
"Climbing is a Quantum Experience" Skyline Forest progress reported by Deschutes Basin Land Trust
Theft of ponderosa pines in the National Forest near Bend, OR
Skyline Forest should be purchased by Deschutes Land Trust!
Hunters who use ATVs are hurting Oregon's elk population
Outdoor folks can help Katrina incident victims now!
An update on the Hart Mountain Antelope Refuge in Oregon
The Store Wars best with broadband!
TraditionalMountaineering adopts the Crooked River through Smith Rock State Park
The Republican Political Party is responsible?
Times Up, by Yvon Chouinard
Nation's forests might be on the road to ruin, by President Bill Clinton
Wilderness at risk from new Bush policies
Steens management scandal may affect wilderness study areas
BLM outsourced Steens Management Plan to mining industry leaders!
Owyhee River wilderness study area inventory with ONDA
OHV vandals charged in Yellowstone
Oregon's B and B Complex fire closure modified
Senate says NO to Big Oil in Alaska
Gloria Flora - Environmental Hero
Re-introducing wolves into Oregon
George Bush overlooking the environment